Could A Backup QB Lead An NFL Team To The 2024 Playoffs? Our Ranking.

David

3 min read

Post on May 25, 2025

4.5

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead an NFL Team to the 2024 Playoffs? Our Ranking

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One moment, a star quarterback is throwing touchdowns; the next, they're sidelined with an injury. This leaves the fate of many teams resting on the shoulders of their backup quarterbacks. But could a backup QB truly lead a team to the playoffs in 2024? It's a question burning on the minds of fans and analysts alike. We've ranked the teams most likely to rely on their backup and their chances of postseason glory.

The Uncertainty Factor: Injury is King (and Queen)

The biggest variable in this equation is, of course, injury. A franchise quarterback going down is never ideal, but the severity and timing of the injury drastically alter the playoff picture. A season-ending injury in Week 1 paints a far different picture than a minor injury sustained late in the season. Teams with strong backup options and capable coaching staffs stand a much better chance of navigating these turbulent waters.

Our Top 5 Contenders (with Backup QB Considerations):

To assess the likelihood of a backup QB leading a team to the playoffs, we considered several factors: the quality of the backup QB, the strength of the supporting cast (offensive line, running game, defense), and the overall team's projected strength of schedule.

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes is the undisputed king, the Chiefs have a history of developing capable backups. Their offensive firepower and strong defense give them a safety net if Mahomes misses time. Probability of Playoff Appearance with Backup QB: High

2. Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' durability has been questioned, making the Eagles' backup situation a critical factor. Their roster is loaded with talent, but their success hinges on competent quarterback play, regardless of who's under center. Probability of Playoff Appearance with Backup QB: Medium-High

3. Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's incredible talent is undeniable, but the Bills need a reliable backup to navigate any potential injury. Their strong supporting cast boosts their chances, even with a less-experienced QB stepping in. Probability of Playoff Appearance with Backup QB: Medium

4. Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow's health is paramount to the Bengals' success. While their offense is potent, their defense needs to significantly improve. A backup quarterback would face a steeper climb to the playoffs. Probability of Playoff Appearance with Backup QB: Medium-Low

5. Dallas Cowboys: Dak Prescott's health is key, but the Cowboys' roster is deep enough to absorb some quarterback uncertainty. Their defense and running game can carry them, but relying heavily on a backup for an extended period could be challenging. Probability of Playoff Appearance with Backup QB: Low-Medium

The Long Shots:

Several other teams could find themselves in a similar situation, but their chances of making a deep playoff run with a backup QB are slimmer. Factors such as weak offensive lines, less-talented backup QBs, or overall weaker team compositions contribute to this lower likelihood.

Conclusion:

While unlikely for most teams, a backup quarterback leading an NFL team to the playoffs in 2024 isn't entirely out of the question. The Chiefs and Eagles appear best positioned to weather the storm should their starting QBs suffer injuries. However, the unpredictable nature of the NFL makes it a thrilling season to watch unfold, regardless of who is under center.

What do you think? Which team's backup quarterback has the best chance of leading their team to playoff glory? Share your predictions in the comments below!