Could A Backup QB Lead An NFL Team To The 2024 Playoffs? A Ranking And Analysis.

David

3 min read

Post on May 26, 2025

5.0

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead an NFL Team to the 2024 Playoffs? A Ranking and Analysis

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One injury, one unexpected slump from a star player, and the entire season can shift dramatically. This brings us to a fascinating question: could a backup quarterback lead an NFL team to the playoffs in 2024? It’s a long shot, but certainly not impossible. This analysis ranks several teams with capable backups and explores the likelihood of a playoff berth under their leadership.

The Unlikely Heroes: Evaluating Backup QB Potential

The success of a backup quarterback hinges on several factors: the quality of the backup himself, the strength of the supporting cast (offensive line, running game, defense), and the overall division competitiveness. Let's analyze some key contenders:

Tier 1: Realistic Playoff Contenders with Strong Backup Options

• 1. Kansas City Chiefs (Backup: Blaine Gabbert): While Patrick Mahomes' injury risk is relatively low given his skill and the Chiefs' protective offensive schemes, Gabbert possesses enough experience to manage games effectively. The Chiefs' overall roster strength gives them a significant advantage. Playoff Potential: High.

• 2. Philadelphia Eagles (Backup: Jalen Hurts): Yes, you read that right. While Hurts is the starter, his injury history highlights the Eagles' need for a robust QB2. Their talent across the board makes them a strong playoff contender even with a slight QB downgrade. Playoff Potential: Medium-High.

Tier 2: Long Shots with Potential for Upset

• 3. Buffalo Bills (Backup: Kyle Allen/Matt Barkley): The Bills' potent offense and elite defense could sustain a short-term absence of Josh Allen. However, the AFC East is fiercely competitive, making a playoff push challenging. Playoff Potential: Medium.

• 4. Cincinnati Bengals (Backup: Jake Browning): Joe Burrow's health is paramount for the Bengals' success. Browning is a less experienced option, and the Bengals’ success relies heavily on Burrow's exceptional play. Playoff Potential: Low.

Tier 3: Unlikely Scenarios

Many other teams possess backup quarterbacks, but their playoff chances hinge heavily on an unlikely confluence of events: a significant drop in performance from the starting QB coupled with a surprisingly strong season from the backup and the rest of the team.

Factors Beyond the Quarterback:

The success of a team led by a backup QB isn't solely dependent on the backup's talent. Other critical factors include:

• Offensive Line Strength: A strong offensive line protects the quarterback and opens running lanes, crucial for any backup succeeding in high-pressure situations.
• Running Game Prowess: A dominant running game can take the pressure off the quarterback, allowing them to make simpler throws and manage the game effectively.
• Defensive Dominance: A strong defense can keep games close, even with a less experienced quarterback under center.

Conclusion: The 2024 Playoffs Remain Uncertain

While the probability of a backup quarterback leading a team to the 2024 NFL playoffs is low, it’s not impossible. Teams with strong supporting casts and capable backups, like the Kansas City Chiefs, have the highest likelihood of making a run. However, the unpredictable nature of the NFL ensures that unexpected outcomes are always on the table. Only time will tell if a backup quarterback will emerge as an unlikely hero this season. Stay tuned!

Call to Action: What team do you think has the best chance of making the playoffs with their backup QB? Share your predictions in the comments below!