Could A Backup QB Lead An NFL Team To A Playoff Victory In 2024? A Ranking.

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 18, 2025

4.8

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead an NFL Team to a Playoff Victory in 2024? A Ranking

The NFL is a league of unexpected twists and turns. Injuries are inevitable, and sometimes, a backup quarterback is thrust into the spotlight. But can a second-string signal-caller truly lead a team to a playoff victory in 2024? It's a question burning on the minds of fans and analysts alike. While unlikely, it's not impossible. Let's rank some teams and their backup QBs, considering their potential for a surprising playoff run should the starter go down.

Factors Considered in Our Ranking:

Before diving into our rankings, it's important to understand the criteria. We've considered several key factors:

• Backup QB Experience: How much NFL experience does the backup have? A seasoned veteran offers a different level of comfort than a rookie.
• Offensive Line Strength: Even the best backup QB needs time in the pocket. A strong offensive line is crucial for success.
• Offensive Scheme: Is the team's offensive system conducive to a backup QB's strengths? A simpler, more run-heavy scheme might be easier to execute.
• Team Roster Strength: A strong supporting cast – a dominant running game, a reliable defense – significantly increases the chances of a successful playoff push.

The Contenders (Ranked):

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes' health is paramount, the Chiefs boast a capable backup in Blaine Gabbert. His experience and familiarity with Andy Reid's system give them a considerable edge. The team's overall strength makes them a top contender even with a backup QB.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts’ injury history makes this a crucial area for the Eagles. Their backup situation is strong, although the specific QB depends on offseason moves. A strong offensive line and running game give them a safety net.

3. Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's durability is a key question mark, although the Bills' offensive prowess gives them a fighting chance. Their backup QB’s performance would greatly influence their playoff success.

4. Dallas Cowboys: Dak Prescott's health is always a topic of conversation. The Cowboys' backup QB will need to step up significantly to lead them through a playoff run, but their strong defense could help compensate for any offensive shortcomings.

5. San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' quarterback situation is consistently fluid. While their system often mitigates the impact of QB changes, the backup's ability to execute the scheme will be critical.

The Long Shots:

Several other teams have capable backups, but their chances of a deep playoff run with a backup QB are slimmer due to less overall team strength or significant experience gaps at the backup position. These include teams like the Cincinnati Bengals, the Baltimore Ravens, and the Miami Dolphins.

The Bottom Line:

While a backup quarterback leading a team to a playoff victory is a long shot, it's not entirely improbable. The teams listed above have the best chance due to a combination of strong supporting casts and relatively experienced backups. However, 2024 will ultimately reveal if a backup QB can truly defy the odds and lead their team to Super Bowl glory.

What are your predictions? Share your thoughts in the comments below!