Could A Backup QB Lead An NFL Team To A 2024 Playoff Victory? A Ranking.

David

3 min read

Post on May 17, 2025

5.0

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead an NFL Team to a 2024 Playoff Victory? A Ranking

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. Injuries are inevitable, and even the most seasoned quarterbacks are susceptible to them. So, the question looms large: could a backup quarterback lead an NFL team to a playoff victory in 2024? It's a long shot, but certainly not impossible. This ranking examines several teams and their backup quarterbacks, assessing their potential to navigate the treacherous path to postseason success.

The Contenders: Assessing Backup QB Potential

To accurately assess the potential for a backup QB-led playoff run, we need to consider several factors: the quality of the backup quarterback themselves, the strength of the supporting cast (offensive line, running game, defense), and the overall team's competitive standing within their division.

Here's a ranking of teams and their backup QBs, considering their chances for a playoff win should their starter go down:

Tier 1: Strong Contenders (Low Probability, High Impact)

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While not a traditional "backup," Shane Buechele has impressed in preseason games. The Chiefs' strong offensive weaponry and dominant defense could carry them even with a less-experienced quarterback at the helm. However, the pressure of replacing Patrick Mahomes is immense.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' durability has been a concern in the past. While Gardner Minshew isn't a star, he's shown competence, and the Eagles' offensive and defensive lines are elite. A playoff win is possible, though unlikely without Hurts.

Tier 2: Possible Dark Horses (Medium Probability, Moderate Impact)

3. Buffalo Bills: The Bills boast a strong offense and a top-tier defense. Their backup situation is less clear, but whoever steps in would inherit a talented team capable of a deep playoff run. The team's success heavily depends on the backup's ability to manage the game.

4. Dallas Cowboys: Cooper Rush has shown flashes of competence in the past. The Cowboys' offense is prolific, and their defense is improving. However, Rush's consistency remains a question mark, making a playoff win a long shot.

Tier 3: Long Shots (Low Probability, Low Impact)

5. San Francisco 49ers: Brock Purdy's injury history is a concern. While the 49ers have a strong roster, relying on a less-experienced backup QB significantly lowers their playoff potential. Their success hinges on the health of their starting quarterback.

6. Baltimore Ravens: Lamar Jackson's health is always a topic of conversation. The Ravens' backup QB situation needs more clarity before a realistic assessment can be made. Their playoff chances drastically decrease without Jackson.

The Factors Beyond the Quarterback

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success isn't solely dependent on their individual talent. The quality of the offensive line, the effectiveness of the running game, and the strength of the defense are all critical components. A strong running game can take pressure off the backup QB, while a solid defense can keep the score manageable.

Conclusion: A Difficult but Not Impossible Task

While a backup quarterback leading an NFL team to a playoff victory in 2024 is a low-probability event, it's not entirely impossible. Teams with strong supporting casts and capable backup quarterbacks have a slightly better chance. Ultimately, the outcome hinges on a combination of factors, including the quarterback's performance, team synergy, and a bit of luck. Stay tuned – the 2024 NFL season promises to be full of surprises.

Call to Action: What do you think? Which backup QB has the best chance of leading their team to a playoff victory? Share your predictions in the comments below!