Could A Backup QB Lead A Team To The 2024 NFL Playoffs? Our Rankings.

David

3 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.1

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead a Team to the 2024 NFL Playoffs? Our Rankings.

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One wrong snap, one devastating injury, and the entire season trajectory can change. This year, the question on many football fans' minds isn't just who will make the playoffs, but who will lead them there. Specifically, could a backup quarterback unexpectedly propel a team to postseason glory in 2024? Let's dive into the possibilities and rank the teams with the most promising backup QB situations.

The Unlikely Heroes: When Backup QBs Shine

The NFL has seen its fair share of backup quarterbacks stepping up to the plate and delivering exceptional performances. Think of Nick Foles' Super Bowl LII victory with the Philadelphia Eagles – a testament to the depth and resilience within the league. While replicating that success is a long shot, several teams possess backup quarterbacks with the potential to guide their squads to unexpected playoff berths. The key factors we'll consider are experience, skillset, and the strength of the surrounding roster.

Our Rankings: Contenders & Dark Horses

We've analyzed several teams and their backup quarterback situations, factoring in both the starter's injury risk and the backup's potential. Here's our ranking, from most to least likely to make a playoff push with their backup QB:

1. The Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes is arguably the league's best quarterback, the Chiefs' backup, Blaine Gabbert, possesses significant NFL experience and understands Andy Reid's offensive system. Their strong roster makes them a strong contender even with a QB change.

2. The Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's injury history makes this a precarious situation, but the Bills have a capable backup in Matt Barkley. Their formidable defense and offensive weapons could carry them through a short-term starter absence.

3. The Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow's health is paramount to the Bengals' success. Their backup situation isn't as clear-cut as others, but the team's offensive firepower could still make them competitive, though relying on a backup QB would significantly decrease their chances.

4. The Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' durability has been a concern. While their backup situation needs clarification, the Eagles' strong roster could help offset any quarterback deficiency.

5. The San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' quarterback room is always a topic of discussion. Brock Purdy's injury recovery is a major factor, but even if he’s healthy, the depth chart behind him is a considerable unknown. Their talent level is high, though their playoff hopes rely heavily on the starter staying healthy.

Factors Beyond the Backup QB

It’s crucial to remember that a successful playoff run with a backup QB requires more than just a competent understudy. Here are some vital contributing factors:

• Strong Offensive and Defensive Lines: A solid offensive line protects the quarterback, while a dominant defense can limit opposing offenses and give the backup more time to adjust.
• Playmaking Skill Positions: Elite receivers, running backs, and tight ends can compensate for a less-experienced quarterback.
• Coaching Staff: A skilled coaching staff can adapt the game plan to maximize the backup's strengths and minimize weaknesses.
• Team Chemistry and Mentality: A team's ability to rally around adversity is crucial in overcoming unexpected challenges.

Conclusion: The Unexpected Playoffs?

While a backup quarterback leading a team to the playoffs is a less common scenario, it's not impossible. The 2024 season will be a fascinating test of depth, resilience, and coaching prowess. Keep an eye on the teams listed above – their ability to navigate potential quarterback injuries could determine their playoff fate. What do you think? Which team has the best chance of making a surprise playoff run with their backup QB? Share your predictions in the comments below!