Could A Backup QB Lead A Playoff Run In 2024? A Realistic Ranking.

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 17, 2025

4.1

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead a Playoff Run in 2024? A Realistic Ranking of Contenders

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One wrong hit, a sudden injury, and the season's trajectory can change dramatically. With the 2024 season looming, a question hangs heavy in the air for many teams: could a backup quarterback lead a legitimate playoff run? The answer, surprisingly, is a nuanced "yes," but with significant caveats. Let's delve into the realistic possibilities and rank the teams best positioned for such a scenario.

The Unlikely Heroes: When Backup QBs Shine

History is littered with instances of backup quarterbacks stepping up and exceeding expectations. Think of Nick Foles' Super Bowl LII victory with the Philadelphia Eagles, or even more recently, the performances of various backups who filled in admirably during injury crises. These moments highlight the inherent talent and preparedness often lurking on the sidelines. However, a playoff run requires more than just a capable arm; it demands consistent leadership, game management, and a supportive team structure.

Factors Favoring a Backup QB Playoff Push:

• Strong Running Game: A dominant rushing attack can significantly alleviate pressure on the backup quarterback, allowing them to focus on game management and short, efficient passes. Teams with established running games are inherently better positioned to weather a starting quarterback injury.
• Elite Defense: A stifling defense can carry a team far, even with a less-than-stellar quarterback. A strong defense minimizes the margin for error, allowing the offense to focus on controlling the clock and avoiding turnovers.
• Offensive Line Prowess: Protecting the quarterback is paramount, regardless of experience. A solid offensive line buys the backup quarterback time to make decisions and limits sacks, increasing their chances of success.
• Offensive Scheme Simplicity: A simpler, less complex offensive scheme allows the backup quarterback to quickly adapt and execute plays effectively, minimizing the learning curve.

Realistic Contender Ranking (2024 Projection):

This ranking considers the above factors and projects potential scenarios for the 2024 season. It's crucial to remember that injuries and unforeseen circumstances can significantly alter this landscape.

1. Philadelphia Eagles: Their potent running game, excellent offensive line, and strong defense make them a prime candidate. Even with a backup quarterback, their overall team strength provides a high likelihood of playoff contention.

2. San Francisco 49ers: Similar to the Eagles, the 49ers boast a powerful running game and a solid defense. Their offensive scheme is designed to limit quarterback burden, making them resilient to QB injuries.

3. Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes is exceptional, the Chiefs possess a strong supporting cast. Their offensive system is adaptable, and their coaching staff is adept at managing QB transitions.

4. Dallas Cowboys: A formidable defense and a capable running game give the Cowboys a fighting chance, although their reliance on a strong passing attack makes them slightly more vulnerable to a QB injury.

5. Buffalo Bills: Their offensive firepower and strong defense make them a threat, but their offensive scheme's reliance on Josh Allen’s unique abilities makes a backup QB scenario less certain.

The Long Shot Contenders:

Several other teams possess elements of a successful backup-led playoff run, but their overall team strength might fall short of the top contenders. These include teams with strong defenses but weaker offensive lines or running games.

Conclusion:

While a backup quarterback leading a team to a deep playoff run is a long shot, it's certainly not impossible. The teams listed above possess the necessary ingredients – a strong running game, a dominant defense, and a supportive offensive system – to potentially weather a quarterback injury and still contend for a Super Bowl berth. The 2024 season promises to be an exciting one, with the potential for some truly remarkable underdog stories. Keep an eye on these teams; their backup quarterbacks might just surprise us all.