Could A Backup QB Lead A 2024 NFL Playoff Team? Ranking The Contenders.

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 05, 2025

4.1

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead a 2024 NFL Playoff Team? Ranking the Contenders

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns, and few scenarios are as dramatic as a backup quarterback stepping up and leading their team to playoff glory. While a starting quarterback is typically the cornerstone of a successful franchise, injuries and unforeseen circumstances can elevate a backup to unexpected stardom. So, as we look ahead to the 2024 NFL season, which teams boast backup quarterbacks with the potential to lead their squads to the postseason? Let's rank the contenders.

The Top Tier: Proven Talent and Supportive Systems

Several teams possess backup quarterbacks with significant experience and the benefit of strong supporting casts. These are the squads most likely to make a deep playoff run even if their starter goes down.

1. The Philadelphia Eagles: While Jalen Hurts' health is paramount, the Eagles' backup situation is enviable. Their current backup, assuming no major roster changes, has already shown flashes of brilliance in limited action. The Eagles’ potent offense and stellar defense provide a safety net, allowing a capable backup quarterback to thrive. Their playoff chances remain high even with an injury to their star QB.

2. The Kansas City Chiefs: Patrick Mahomes' health is arguably the most important factor in the Chiefs’ success, but Andy Reid’s coaching prowess and the team's overall talent give them a significant advantage. Their backup quarterback, whoever that may be in 2024, will inherit a well-oiled machine capable of competing at a high level. The Chiefs' system consistently elevates quarterbacks, regardless of their experience level.

The Middle Tier: Potential, but Uncertainty Remains

These teams have backups with potential, but several factors could hinder their playoff aspirations if the starter is injured.

3. The Buffalo Bills: The Bills boast a strong roster, but the reliance on Josh Allen is undeniable. Their backup quarterback's performance in the event of an injury would be crucial to their playoff success. The offensive line's effectiveness and the overall consistency of the team would be key factors here.

4. The Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow’s health is critical for the Bengals. Their backup needs to be ready to step into a high-pressure situation and perform at a high level against top competition. Success would depend on their ability to execute the Bengals' offensive scheme effectively.

The Long Shot: High Risk, High Reward

These teams possess backups with less proven NFL experience. Their playoff hopes hinge heavily on their starter remaining healthy and the backup’s ability to make a significant leap in performance.

5. The Dallas Cowboys: While the Cowboys possess a talented roster, their backup quarterback situation presents a higher degree of risk compared to the teams mentioned above. Their playoff success in a scenario where their starter suffers an injury hinges entirely on their backup's unforeseen capabilities.

Factors Beyond the Quarterback:

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success isn't solely dependent on individual talent. Several factors contribute to a team's ability to overcome a starting quarterback injury:

• Offensive Line Strength: A strong offensive line provides crucial protection and time for the backup to make plays.
• Offensive Scheme Simplicity: A simpler, more adaptable offensive system allows the backup quarterback to quickly grasp the game plan.
• Strong Running Game: A reliable running game can take pressure off the backup quarterback and control the clock.
• Defensive Prowess: A dominant defense can keep games close, even with a less experienced quarterback under center.

Conclusion:

While any team's playoff hopes are significantly diminished by a starting quarterback injury, some teams are better equipped than others to weather the storm. The Eagles and Chiefs stand out as the most likely contenders to make a deep playoff run even with their backup quarterback under center. However, unexpected performances from less-heralded backups could change the dynamics of the 2024 NFL season. Stay tuned for the exciting developments to come!