Could A Backup QB Lead A 2024 NFL Playoff Contender? Our Rankings.

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 16, 2025

4.6

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead a 2024 NFL Playoff Contender? Our Rankings

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One moment, a star quarterback is leading their team to victory; the next, they're sidelined with an injury, leaving the fate of a potential playoff contender in the hands of their backup. So, the question begs: Can a backup quarterback truly steer a team to postseason success in 2024? We've ranked the backup quarterbacks most likely to do just that.

The prospect of a backup QB leading a playoff charge is tantalizing, yet fraught with uncertainty. It hinges on a delicate balance of factors: the quality of the backup themselves, the strength of the supporting cast (offensive and defensive lines, running game, receiving corps), and, of course, a significant dose of luck. This year, more than ever, the depth chart behind the starting quarterback is a crucial factor for NFL general managers.

Our Methodology:

Our rankings consider a variety of factors beyond simple stats. We've analyzed:

• Experience: How many starts and significant playing time does the backup have under their belt? A player with extensive experience, even if not always as a starter, carries a significant advantage.
• System Fit: How well does the backup fit the team's offensive system? A quarterback comfortable within the existing scheme will be far more effective than one needing significant adjustments.
• Supporting Cast: The strength of the offensive line, running backs, and receivers is paramount. Even a highly skilled backup will struggle with a weak supporting cast.
• Team Strength: A team with a strong defense and special teams units significantly increases the backup's chances of success. A weaker team, even with a capable backup, faces an uphill battle.

The Top 5 Backup QBs Most Likely to Lead a Playoff Contender in 2024:

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season performance in 2022 showed incredible poise and talent. While still recovering from injury, his understanding of Kyle Shanahan's offensive system gives him a significant edge. The 49ers' roster is stacked, making him a strong contender for this top spot.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has proven he can win games in the NFL, filling in admirably for Dak Prescott in the past. With a strong offensive line and a potent running game supporting him, the Cowboys remain a dangerous team even if Prescott were to miss time.

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has a track record of performing well given the opportunity. While the Colts' overall success remains uncertain, Minshew's experience and ability could make him a key player if the starting quarterback falters.

4. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe's performance in limited appearances last season showcased promise. The Patriots' system emphasizes a strong running game and a robust defense, making Zappe a potentially viable option if called upon.

5. Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders): Brissett is a proven veteran with extensive experience. While his ceiling may be lower than others on this list, his reliability and familiarity with the NFL landscape make him a valuable asset to Washington.

The Wildcard: It's impossible to predict injuries perfectly. Keep an eye on teams like the Philadelphia Eagles, Buffalo Bills, and Kansas City Chiefs. While their backups might not be as highly ranked, the sheer talent of their starting quarterbacks makes them potential contenders regardless of who's under center.

Conclusion:

While predicting the future in the NFL is an inherently risky business, several backup quarterbacks possess the potential to lead their teams to playoff contention in 2024. The ultimate success will depend on a combination of their own skill, the strength of their team's supporting cast, and a little bit of luck. But the possibility remains a captivating storyline for the upcoming season. Stay tuned for updates throughout the year!