Contenders Or Pretenders? Ranking Backup QBs For A 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 20, 2025

4.5

Share

Contenders or Pretenders? Ranking Backup QBs for a 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and even the most robust starting quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. A team's success often hinges not just on their star players, but the depth of their roster. This year, the backup quarterback position holds particular significance, potentially determining the difference between a playoff berth and an early offseason. So, let's dive into a ranking of backup quarterbacks and assess their potential to lead their teams to a 2024 playoff bid should the starter go down.

Tier 1: The Potential Playoff Saviors

This tier encompasses quarterbacks who have proven themselves capable of leading NFL offenses, even if their starting experience is limited. These backups aren't just holding the clipboard; they're genuine contenders for playoff success.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022, culminating in a playoff run before injury, catapults him to the top of this list. His poise and accuracy under pressure are undeniable assets. The 49ers' strong offensive line and talented receiving corps would certainly give him a significant advantage should he need to step in.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has consistently proven his ability to keep the Cowboys competitive whenever called upon. His familiarity with the system and his experience filling in for Dak Prescott make him a valuable asset. However, his ceiling might be lower than Purdy's in a prolonged starting role.

3. Teddy Bridgewater (Miami Dolphins): A veteran presence with starting experience, Bridgewater offers stability and experience. While not possessing the explosive upside of some other backups, his consistency and leadership could guide the Dolphins through a tough stretch.

Tier 2: The Capable Fill-Ins

This tier includes quarterbacks who are capable of winning games, but perhaps lack the same level of proven success or the surrounding talent as Tier 1. They could keep their teams afloat but might not be able to lead a deep playoff run.

1. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew possesses a strong arm and a fearless playing style. While his consistency can be questioned, he's shown flashes of brilliance and could keep the Colts competitive in the right circumstances. However, the Colts' overall roster strength will heavily influence his potential success.

2. Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders): Brissett's experience makes him a valuable asset to the Commanders. He's a reliable game manager who can avoid turnovers, but he's unlikely to elevate the team beyond their current capabilities.

Tier 3: The Question Marks

These backups have limited starting experience or have displayed inconsistencies in their performances. Their ability to lead a team to the playoffs would be a significant uphill battle.

1. Many other NFL backups: The reality is that many backup quarterbacks across the league are young, inexperienced players or veterans past their prime. While some could perform adequately in a pinch, expecting a playoff run from these teams if their starters go down is unrealistic. This highlights the importance of strong quarterback depth for every team.

The Impact of Supporting Cast

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success isn't solely dependent on their individual talent. The quality of the offensive line, the receiving corps, and the overall coaching staff are all critical factors. A talented backup on a weaker team might struggle more than a less talented backup on a stronger team.

Conclusion: Preparing for the Unexpected

The NFL is a game of inches and often unforeseen circumstances. While no team wants their starting quarterback to miss time, having a capable backup can be the difference between a successful season and a disappointing one. Teams with strong backup quarterbacks like the 49ers and Cowboys enter the season with a significant advantage, while others face a higher degree of uncertainty. The 2024 playoff race will likely be influenced by the performance of these unsung heroes, ready to step into the spotlight when called upon. Stay tuned to see which backups rise to the occasion and solidify their team's playoff aspirations.