Contenders Or Pretenders? Evaluating Backup NFL QBs For A 2024 Playoff Push

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 20, 2025

4.8

Share

Contenders or Pretenders? Evaluating Backup NFL QBs for a 2024 Playoff Push

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and injuries are an inevitable part of the game. For many teams, the difference between a playoff berth and an early offseason lies not with their star quarterbacks, but with the reliability of their backups. As we look ahead to the 2024 season, let's delve into the crucial question: which backup quarterbacks are genuine contenders, capable of stepping up when called upon, and which are merely pretenders, likely to sink their team's playoff hopes?

The Elite Few: Proven Commodities

Several teams boast backup quarterbacks who inspire confidence. These aren't just clipboard holders; they're seasoned veterans with proven track records.

• The Case of Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's unexpected playoff run in 2023 solidified his status as a top-tier backup. While his future remains uncertain due to injury, his performance last season demonstrated his potential to lead a team to success. His ability to manage the game and make key throws under pressure is a significant asset for the 49ers.

• Veteran Stability: Teams like the Buffalo Bills (with Kyle Allen) and the Kansas City Chiefs (with Blaine Gabbert) benefit from experienced backups. These quarterbacks may not be flashy, but they provide stability and familiarity within the offense, minimizing disruption in the event of an injury to the starter. Their understanding of the playbook and ability to execute the offense are invaluable assets.

The Rising Stars: Potential Playmakers

Several younger quarterbacks possess the potential to blossom into reliable backups, potentially even future starters.

• The Next Generation: Players like Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons) and Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans) are still developing but showed flashes of potential in limited playing time. Their athleticism and upside are enticing, but consistency and experience remain key areas for improvement. Their development will be crucial in determining whether they become legitimate playoff contenders for their respective teams.

• The Intrigue Factor: The upcoming draft and free agency period will introduce new faces to the backup QB landscape. These players offer a gamble, with the potential for a diamond in the rough, but also the risk of adding an unproven commodity.

The Questionable Choices: Potential Downfalls

Unfortunately, not every team can boast a reliable backup. Some teams face significant question marks at the position.

• The Risk of Inexperience: Relying on a completely inexperienced backup presents a significant risk. While the potential for a surprise success exists, the likelihood of a significant drop-off in performance is substantial. This lack of experience can derail even the most talented teams.

• The Importance of Practice Squad Depth: Teams must focus on developing players on their practice squads. These players provide a safety net and a chance for future development. Investing time and resources into improving the practice squad's quarterback depth is crucial for long-term success.

Looking Ahead to 2024:

The upcoming season will be a critical test for many backup quarterbacks. Their performance could determine the fate of their teams’ playoff hopes. Teams must prioritize building depth at the quarterback position; a strong backup isn't just insurance – it's a vital component of a successful NFL team. The difference between a contender and a pretender might just be found on the sidelines. Keep an eye on these players; their performance in 2024 could write the narrative of their team's season.

Call to Action: Who do you believe is the most underrated backup QB heading into 2024? Share your thoughts in the comments below!