College Football Playoff Expansion: Sankey's 5+11 Model Meeting With SEC Coaches

David

3 min read

Post on May 29, 2025

4.6

Share

College Football Playoff Expansion: Sankey's 5+11 Model Faces SEC Scrutiny

The College Football Playoff (CFP) expansion debate continues to rage, with the latest development centering on SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey's proposed "5+11" model and its reception among SEC coaches. This innovative approach, aiming to increase the playoff field from four to twelve teams, has sparked intense discussion, raising questions about its feasibility and impact on the sport's landscape.

Sankey's model, unveiled during a recent meeting with SEC coaches, suggests a structure that prioritizes conference champions. Five automatic qualifying bids would be granted to the champions of the five highest-ranked conferences (likely the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12, and SEC), leaving seven at-large bids to be contested amongst the remaining deserving teams. This system attempts to balance tradition with competitive fairness, a delicate balancing act that has proven difficult to achieve.

The 5+11 Model: A Closer Look

The "5+11" model aims to address several key concerns plaguing the current four-team playoff system. These concerns include:

• Lack of Representation for Strong Non-Power Five Teams: The current system often excludes highly deserving teams from outside the Power Five conferences. Sankey's proposal addresses this by ensuring at least seven additional teams from a wider range of conferences can contend for a playoff spot.
• Increased Parity and Excitement: A larger playoff field promises more exciting matchups and a longer, more dramatic postseason. This should translate to increased fan engagement and media interest.
• Revenue Generation: An expanded playoff is expected to significantly boost revenue for the CFP and its member conferences, potentially leading to greater investments in college athletics.

However, the proposal wasn't without its critics. While some SEC coaches voiced support, others expressed reservations. The primary concern revolves around the potential impact on the SEC’s dominance. With the SEC consistently fielding several top-ranked teams, the 5+11 model might actually reduce the conference's chances of having multiple teams in the CFP, unlike the current system where multiple SEC teams have frequently clashed in the playoff.

Challenges and Potential Alternatives

The implementation of the 5+11 model faces several hurdles. These include:

• Selection Committee Power: The selection committee's role would be significantly amplified, increasing the pressure to make transparent and justifiable choices.
• Conference Alignment: The model relies on a clear hierarchy of conferences, which could be challenging to establish and maintain amidst shifting conference realignment dynamics.
• Scheduling Conflicts: An expanded playoff requires adjustments to the regular season schedule, potentially creating scheduling complications and logistical challenges.

Alternatives to the 5+11 model are still under consideration. Some proposals favor a simpler 12-team playoff with a broader range of qualifying criteria. Others suggest prioritizing strength of schedule over conference affiliation. The final decision will hinge on a complex negotiation involving numerous stakeholders, highlighting the considerable challenges involved in reforming the CFP.

The Future of College Football Playoff Expansion

The future of the CFP remains uncertain, but the discussions surrounding Sankey's 5+11 model have pushed the conversation forward. While the model presents a compelling compromise between tradition and expansion, its ultimate fate will depend on finding consensus among the various conferences and stakeholders. The ongoing debate highlights the immense complexity of balancing fairness, tradition, and competitive dynamics in the ever-evolving landscape of college football. The coming months will be crucial in determining the shape of college football’s postseason for years to come. What are your thoughts on the 5+11 model? Share your opinions in the comments below!