Christian McCaffrey & Mark Andrews: Why These Players Are Fantasy Football Risks

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 03, 2025

4.2

Share

Christian McCaffrey & Mark Andrews: Why These Top Fantasy Football Picks Are Risky Bets in 2024

The fantasy football draft season is upon us, and two names consistently dominate early-round picks: Christian McCaffrey and Mark Andrews. But are these seemingly surefire studs actually risky picks for your 2024 fantasy team? Let's delve into the potential pitfalls of drafting these high-profile players.

While their talent is undeniable, several factors contribute to the inherent risk associated with selecting McCaffrey and Andrews so high. Ignoring these potential downsides could leave your fantasy season in tatters.

Christian McCaffrey: The Injury Enigma

Christian McCaffrey's exceptional talent is matched only by his injury history. He's a workhorse back, consistently racking up touches, but this high volume significantly increases his risk of injury. [Link to McCaffrey's injury history - external source, e.g., ESPN or NFL.com]. This isn't a question of if he'll get injured, but when. A significant injury could derail your entire fantasy season, leaving you scrambling to fill a crucial position.

• High-volume workload: McCaffrey's role demands significant carries and receptions, increasing wear and tear.
• Past injuries: His extensive injury history is a significant red flag, highlighting a vulnerability to setbacks.
• Age: While still relatively young, the cumulative effect of years of intense play cannot be ignored.

Even a minor injury can significantly impact his production, forcing owners to rely on less reliable backups. Remember the frustration of watching your top pick sidelined week after week? This is a real possibility with McCaffrey.

Mark Andrews: The Tight End Ceiling

Mark Andrews is a phenomenal tight end, consistently delivering strong fantasy performances. However, even elite tight ends face limitations. The inherent volatility of the tight end position, coupled with potential offensive scheme changes or quarterback inconsistencies, introduces considerable risk.

• Dependence on Lamar Jackson: Andrews' production is heavily tied to Lamar Jackson's performance and health. Jackson's own injury history presents a risk factor.
• Offensive scheme changes: Changes to the Ravens' offensive strategy could potentially reduce Andrews' target share.
• Emerging Tight End Talent: The NFL is seeing an influx of incredibly talented tight ends, creating more competition for targets.

While Andrews is undoubtedly a top-tier tight end, relying on him as a cornerstone of your fantasy team carries more risk than selecting a more consistent, less volatile player in a later round. The potential for disappointment is significant.

Mitigating the Risk: Drafting Strategies

So, should you avoid McCaffrey and Andrews altogether? Not necessarily. But understanding the risks involved is crucial for smart drafting. Consider these strategies:

• Late-round RB/TE insurance: Draft a strong backup running back and tight end to mitigate the potential loss of your early-round picks.
• Avoid reaching: Don't overdraft these players. If you can get similar value later in the draft, you may be better off.
• Consider your overall draft strategy: Build a balanced team with reliable players across all positions rather than relying heavily on a few high-risk, high-reward players.

Conclusion:

Christian McCaffrey and Mark Andrews are undoubtedly talented players capable of delivering fantasy gold. However, their injury history and positional volatility make them risky picks in the early rounds of your fantasy draft. Carefully weigh the potential rewards against the significant risks before making your decision. A well-rounded team with dependable players across all positions is often a more successful strategy than relying on a few high-profile, high-risk players. Remember to conduct thorough research and develop a strong draft strategy before making your picks!