Can These Backup QBs Deliver A 2024 NFL Playoff Run? A Comprehensive Ranking

David

3 min read

Post on May 22, 2025

4.0

Share

Can These Backup QBs Deliver a 2024 NFL Playoff Run? A Comprehensive Ranking

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns, and few things can derail a season faster than a starting quarterback injury. With the 2024 season looming, several teams are relying on the strength of their backup quarterbacks to keep playoff hopes alive. But can these understudies truly deliver when the pressure is on? We've ranked the backup QBs with the highest potential to lead their teams to a postseason berth, considering experience, talent, and system fit.

The Contenders: A Tiered Approach

We've divided the backup QBs into tiers based on their projected ability to lead a playoff run. This ranking considers factors beyond just statistics, encompassing their familiarity with the offensive system, their past performance (if any), and the overall strength of their supporting cast.

Tier 1: The Elite Potential

This tier features quarterbacks who possess the talent and experience to potentially carry a team deep into the playoffs should the starter go down.

• 1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's surprising late-season success in 2022 catapults him to the top of this list. His strong arm, quick decision-making, and ability to thrive under pressure make him a legitimate threat. The 49ers' offensive system, already a powerhouse, further enhances his potential. However, his injury history is a significant concern.

• 2. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): Love finally gets his chance to prove himself as the Packers' starter. While unproven in a starting role, his pre-season performances have been promising. His arm strength and athleticism give him a high ceiling, but his consistency will be key. The Packers' offensive scheme, while in transition, still provides plenty of talent around him.

Tier 2: Solid Potential, Higher Risk

These quarterbacks have shown flashes of potential, but their inexperience or inconsistencies create a higher degree of risk.

• 3. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed improvement towards the end of the 2023 season, showcasing better decision-making and mobility. He'll need to continue developing his accuracy and consistency to be a true playoff contender. The Falcons' offense, built around a strong run game, provides a solid foundation.

• 4. Will Levis (Tennessee Titans): Levis is a high-risk, high-reward prospect. His arm talent is undeniable, but he needs to refine his decision-making and improve his consistency. His success will heavily depend on the Titans' offensive line and coaching staff.

Tier 3: Uncertainty and Question Marks

This tier includes quarterbacks with limited experience or significant question marks surrounding their ability to perform at a high level.

• 5. Backup QBs across the league: Many teams rely on quarterbacks with limited NFL experience or those who haven't shown consistent success at the professional level. While some might surprise, relying on these backups for a deep playoff run is a considerable gamble.

Factors Beyond the Quarterback:

It’s crucial to remember that a successful playoff run relies on more than just the quarterback. A strong offensive line, a capable running game, a reliable defense, and a cohesive coaching staff are all essential ingredients for postseason success. Even the most talented backup QB will struggle without the necessary supporting cast.

Conclusion: Hope Springs Eternal, But Reality Bites

While some backup quarterbacks possess the potential to lead their teams to the playoffs, the reality is that replacing a starting QB is rarely seamless. The teams with the most realistic playoff hopes in case of injury are those with strong supporting casts and quarterbacks like Purdy and Love who've demonstrated greater potential at the NFL level. The 2024 season will undoubtedly provide compelling storylines as these backup QBs face the ultimate test. Will they rise to the occasion, or will injuries ultimately determine the fate of their teams? Only time will tell.

(CTA: What do you think? Which backup QB has the best chance to lead their team to a playoff run? Share your predictions in the comments below!)