Can Backup QBs Lead NFL Playoff Runs In 2024? Ranking The Contenders

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 04, 2025

4.3

Share

Can Backup QBs Lead NFL Playoff Runs in 2024? Ranking the Contenders

The NFL playoffs are a crucible, testing teams to their limits. While star quarterbacks often lead the charge, the 2024 postseason could see a surprising number of backup signal-callers thrust into the spotlight. Injuries are an inevitable part of the brutal NFL season, and the ability of a team's backup quarterback to step up could be the difference between a Super Bowl run and an early exit. So, which backup QBs have the potential to lead their teams deep into January? Let's rank the contenders.

The Top Tier: Proven Commodities

Several teams boast backup quarterbacks with significant NFL experience. These players aren't just clipboard holders; they've shown flashes of brilliance and possess the leadership qualities necessary to navigate high-pressure playoff situations.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022 proved his mettle. While a significant injury complicates his 2024 outlook, his past performance places him at the top of this list. If healthy, he's a legitimate threat to lead the 49ers far into the playoffs. His quick release and ability to improvise make him a valuable asset.

2. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has proven to be a capable game manager with a knack for making clutch plays. His experience and familiarity with NFL systems give him an edge. While the Colts' success hinges largely on their overall roster strength, Minshew offers a level of competence that inspires confidence.

3. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush stepped in admirably for Dak Prescott in 2022, showing he can win games at the NFL level. His understanding of the Cowboys' offensive scheme is invaluable. While he might not possess the same ceiling as some other backups, his reliability makes him a key player for Dallas' playoff aspirations.

The Second Tier: Potential Dark Horses

This group includes quarterbacks with less starting experience but possessing significant potential. Their performance will heavily depend on the specific circumstances and the supporting cast around them.

4. Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis possesses incredible physical tools and a high ceiling. He needs more refinement, but his arm talent and running ability could make him a wildcard in a playoff scenario. The Titans' success will greatly depend on how well Willis develops throughout the season.

5. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed glimpses of promise in his limited starts last season. His athleticism and strong arm give him the potential for a breakout performance if given the opportunity. His future hinges on continued development and improvement within the Falcons' system.

The Long Shot: Unproven Commodities

This category consists of backups with limited NFL experience. Their performance would be a major surprise, but stranger things have happened in the NFL.

6. Several Undetermined Backups: Many teams' backup QB situations are still fluid during the pre-season. Undrafted free agents, late-round picks, and veteran free agent signings could emerge as potential candidates if their starting quarterbacks suffer injuries.

Conclusion: Backup QB Success Depends on Multiple Factors

The success of a backup quarterback in the NFL playoffs isn't solely dependent on their individual talent. A strong offensive line, a reliable running game, and a solid defense are all crucial factors. The coaching staff's ability to adjust the game plan to the backup's strengths is also paramount. While some backups have a higher ceiling than others, the 2024 NFL playoffs could see several surprise performances from unlikely heroes. Stay tuned to see who rises to the occasion. Keep an eye on training camp battles and injury reports as the season unfolds – the quarterback depth chart is a constantly evolving story.