By The Numbers: A Deep Dive Into The Careers Of Kershaw And Scherzer

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 10, 2025

4.6

Share

By the Numbers: A Deep Dive into the Hall of Fame Careers of Kershaw and Scherzer

Clayton Kershaw and Max Scherzer. Two pitching titans who have dominated Major League Baseball for over a decade. Their careers, filled with Cy Young Awards, no-hitters, and countless strikeouts, are the stuff of legend. But how do their incredible accomplishments stack up against each other, by the numbers? This deep dive compares these pitching greats, offering a statistical showdown that will leave even the most seasoned baseball fan impressed.

The Cy Young Showdown: A Tale of Two Aces

Both Kershaw and Scherzer are multiple-time Cy Young Award winners, a testament to their consistent dominance. Kershaw, with three Cy Youngs (2011, 2013, 2014), has established himself as one of the best left-handed pitchers of all time. His pinpoint control and devastating curveball have baffled batters for years. Scherzer, on the other hand, boasts three Cy Young awards of his own (2013, 2016, 2017), showcasing his incredible power pitching and fierce competitiveness. The fact that they both won in the same year (2013) speaks to their incredible talent and the era's high level of pitching.

Wins, Losses, and ERA: A Statistical Comparison

While wins aren't always the best indicator of a pitcher's skill, it's a stat fans love. Kershaw currently holds a slight edge in career wins, showcasing his longevity and consistent performance. However, Scherzer's higher strikeout rate often leads to more high-pressure situations, potentially impacting his win-loss record. Analyzing their earned run averages (ERAs) offers a more precise picture of their pitching prowess. Both boast remarkably low ERAs throughout their careers, highlighting their ability to consistently limit runs. A detailed year-by-year comparison would reveal fascinating insights into their peak performance years and any periods of relative struggle.

Strikeouts, WHIP, and Beyond: The Nitty Gritty

Beyond the headline stats, a deeper dive into strikeouts per nine innings (K/9), walks plus hits per inning pitched (WHIP), and other advanced metrics provides a truly comprehensive comparison. Scherzer’s aggressive approach often results in higher strikeout totals, a testament to his overpowering arsenal. Kershaw, while perhaps more reliant on finesse, maintains an impressively low WHIP, showcasing his exceptional command and ability to keep runners off base. Analyzing these more nuanced statistics provides a more complete picture of their distinct pitching styles and overall effectiveness.

Postseason Performances: October Magic

The postseason is where legends are made or broken. Both Kershaw and Scherzer have experienced both the highs and lows of October baseball. Kershaw's playoff struggles, despite his regular season dominance, have been a point of discussion among fans and analysts alike. Conversely, Scherzer's postseason performance has been more consistently impressive, although even he has experienced tough moments on the biggest stage. Comparing their postseason statistics, including ERA, wins, and strikeouts, adds another layer to their comparative analysis.

The Legacy: Future Hall of Famers?

There's little doubt that both Kershaw and Scherzer will be enshrined in Cooperstown. The numbers speak for themselves: incredible regular season dominance, Cy Young Awards, and a lasting impact on the game. The question isn't if they'll be Hall of Famers, but how their legacies will be remembered and compared in the future. Will Scherzer’s higher strikeout totals and possibly more wins tip the scales? Or will Kershaw's longevity and consistent brilliance solidify his place as the superior pitcher? Only time, and the Hall of Fame voters, will tell.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts? Who do you think has had the better career – Kershaw or Scherzer? Share your opinion in the comments below!