Assessing The Best Backup Quarterbacks: A 2024 NFL Playoff Contender Analysis

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 01, 2025

4.3

Share

Assessing the Best Backup Quarterbacks: A 2024 NFL Playoff Contender Analysis

The NFL playoffs are a brutal crucible. One injury to a starting quarterback can shatter even the most meticulously crafted Super Bowl aspirations. This makes the quality of a backup quarterback arguably the most underrated factor influencing a team's postseason chances. So, which teams boast the best backups heading into the 2024 season, and which ones should be sweating bullets? Let's dive into an analysis of the top backup quarterbacks poised to make a difference.

The Elite Tier: More Than Just a Warm Body

Several teams possess backups who could realistically start for many NFL teams. These aren't just emergency options; they're legitimate threats to win games.

• The Kansas City Chiefs (Blaine Gabbert): While not a flashy name, Gabbert brings valuable experience and a familiarity with Andy Reid's offensive system. His steady hand could keep the Chiefs afloat should Patrick Mahomes face an injury. His understanding of the playbook is invaluable in high-pressure situations.
• The Philadelphia Eagles (Jalen Hurts' Potential Replacement): The Eagles haven't publicly named a clear-cut backup, and that might be their most potent strategy. The competition for the backup spot will push every contender to perform at a high level during training camp and the pre-season games. This intense competition will ultimately result in a better quality backup QB.
• The Buffalo Bills (Matt Barkley/Others): The Bills' situation is intriguing. While they haven't solidified a clear number two, their coaching staff prioritizes developing capable backups. Their scouting and player development system suggests a strong potential candidate will emerge before the start of the season. This focus will ensure a competent backup QB is available if needed.

The Solid Middle Tier: Capable, But With Limitations

This group of backups offers a decent level of competence, but they might not be able to carry a team to a deep playoff run if thrust into a starting role. Their strengths lie in game management and preventing catastrophic turnovers.

• The Dallas Cowboys (Cooper Rush): Rush has proven his ability to win games, stepping in admirably for Dak Prescott in the past. However, he's not a high-ceiling option.
• The Cincinnati Bengals (Jake Browning): The Bengals’ backup situation is a bit less secure. Their strategy of focusing on young talent is risky, but could pay off with a diamond in the rough.

The Risky Business Tier: Hope for the Best, Prepare for the Worst

These teams are in a precarious position. Their backup quarterbacks offer limited upside and could severely hinder their playoff aspirations if the starter goes down. This is where the real concern lies for many playoff contenders.

• Teams needing significant upgrades: Several teams, including some who made it to the playoffs last year, lack a reliable backup quarterback. Their offseason moves will be closely watched. Their lack of depth could easily derail their season. These teams should prioritize improving this position group through the draft, free agency, or trade during the off-season.

The Importance of Pre-Season Games

The upcoming preseason games will provide crucial insight into the performance of backup quarterbacks. Teams and fans will keenly watch to assess their abilities under pressure and game-like conditions. These games are not just about evaluating rookies; they are also a critical time for assessing the reliability of backup quarterbacks.

Conclusion:

The backup quarterback position is often overlooked, but its importance cannot be overstated. Teams with reliable backups enter the playoffs with a significant advantage. The 2024 season will be fascinating to watch, particularly for how the backup quarterbacks perform when (and if) called upon. Keep a close eye on the preseason games and roster moves to see how the landscape shifts. The quality of a team's backup quarterback could very well be the difference between a Super Bowl run and an early exit.