Assessing The Best Backup QBs: Predicting A 2024 NFL Playoff Impact

David

3 min read

Post on May 17, 2025

4.4

Share

Assessing the Best Backup QBs: Predicting a 2024 NFL Playoff Impact

The NFL is a brutal league. One injury, especially at the quarterback position, can derail even the most promising season. That's why having a capable backup quarterback isn't just a luxury—it's a necessity for any team hoping to make a deep playoff run in 2024. But which backup QBs are truly playoff-ready? Let's dive into an assessment of some of the league's top second-string signal-callers and predict their potential impact.

The Elite Tier: Proven Performers Ready to Step Up

Several teams boast backup quarterbacks with significant starting experience and a proven track record of success. These are the players who could seamlessly step into a starting role and maintain, or even improve, their team's playoff chances.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's unexpected late-season surge in 2022 showcased his resilience and talent. While his health remains a question mark after elbow surgery, a healthy Purdy represents a significant upgrade over many starting quarterbacks in the league. His presence alone adds a layer of insurance to the 49ers' already formidable playoff aspirations.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush consistently demonstrates reliability and a cool head under pressure. While not a flashy player, his experience in the Cowboys' system and his ability to manage games make him a valuable asset. His potential impact in the playoffs depends heavily on the health of Dak Prescott, but if called upon, he can keep the Cowboys competitive.

• Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew’s exciting playing style and experience provide the Colts with a capable backup. While his performance has been inconsistent, his arm talent and ability to make plays outside of structure could make him a difference-maker should Anthony Richardson face injury.

The Rising Stars: Potential for Playoff Contributions

This group features quarterbacks with less starting experience but substantial potential to contribute meaningfully in the playoffs if given the opportunity. Their development and readiness will be crucial factors in their team's success.

• Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis has the tools, but consistency remains a challenge. His athleticism and strong arm could be valuable in a playoff situation, especially in short-yardage situations. However, his inexperience is a factor that could hinder his playoff performance.

• Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed promise towards the end of last season, suggesting growth and potential. His development will be key to determining his playoff readiness, but he certainly has a higher ceiling than many other backups in the league.

The Wild Cards: Unproven but Potentially Valuable

This category includes quarterbacks who haven't had significant NFL experience but possess traits that could surprise. Their success hinges on quick adaptation and seizing unexpected opportunities.

• Several Undrafted Free Agents and Practice Squad QBs: Many teams rely on young, unproven quarterbacks on their practice squads. These individuals may surprise with their performance if thrust into the spotlight but their impact remains highly uncertain.

The Importance of Backup QB Development

The success of a team's playoff hopes often rests on the shoulders of the backup quarterback. Investing in their development, providing them with ample practice opportunities, and integrating them seamlessly into the offensive system is crucial for any NFL team aiming for a Super Bowl. Teams that prioritize this aspect of their roster management will stand a much better chance of navigating the unexpected challenges of the season and succeeding in the postseason.

Looking Ahead to 2024

The 2024 NFL season promises exciting matchups and unpredictable twists. The quality of backup quarterbacks will play a significant role in determining which teams advance to, and ultimately win, the playoffs. Keeping a close eye on the development and performance of these players will be essential for any serious NFL fan. Keep checking back for updates as the season progresses!