Assessing The Best Backup QBs: NFL Playoff Contenders For 2024

David

3 min read

Post on May 26, 2025

4.9

Share

Assessing the Best Backup QBs: NFL Playoff Contenders for 2024

The NFL playoffs are a brutal crucible. One injury to a starting quarterback can shatter even the most promising season. For teams harboring Super Bowl aspirations in 2024, the quality of their backup quarterback is no longer a luxury, but a crucial factor determining playoff success. This year, some teams boast significantly stronger backup options than others, raising the stakes for those clinging to the fringes of contention. Let's dive into assessing the best backup quarterbacks among the NFL's playoff contenders.

Tier 1: The Elite Backups – Ready to Start Any Day

This tier features quarterbacks who could realistically step in and win games, not just manage a few drives. Their experience, talent, and familiarity with their offensive systems make them invaluable assets.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's surprising performance last season, culminating in a strong playoff run before injury, catapulted him into this elite category. His quick release, accuracy, and leadership skills make him a legitimate starter-caliber backup. The 49ers are in a strong position with him behind the seemingly indestructible Mr. Irrelevant.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer in limited opportunities, Rush has proven he can keep the Cowboys competitive. His understanding of Kellen Moore's offensive system and ability to manage games make him a vital piece of Dallas’ success.

• Teddy Bridgewater (Miami Dolphins): Bridgewater’s veteran presence and experience offer the Dolphins a sense of security. While not a flashy option, his game management and reliability are highly valued for a team hoping to make a deep playoff push.

Tier 2: Capable Hands – Experienced and Reliable

This tier includes quarterbacks who might not be star-caliber starters but offer a degree of competence and experience should they be called upon. They’re reliable game managers who can keep the team afloat.

• Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders): Brissett has shown consistency throughout his career and is a solid, if unspectacular, backup option. His experience and familiarity with the NFL's intricacies give the Commanders peace of mind.

• Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has a reputation for exciting plays and improvisational skills. While he can be prone to mistakes, his talent makes him a better option than many other backup quarterbacks. The Colts may be looking for another option in 2024 but Minshew represents solid depth.

Tier 3: Developing Potential – The Unknowns

This group comprises quarterbacks with limited NFL experience. Their upside is there, but their readiness for a starting role remains uncertain. This tier carries significant risk for playoff contenders.

• Many Teams: Several teams rely on relatively inexperienced quarterbacks as their backups, which presents a significant risk during the playoffs. These teams may need to consider strengthening their backup position in the off-season through free agency or the draft.

The Importance of Backup QB in Playoff Contention

The importance of a reliable backup quarterback cannot be overstated. Teams with weak backup options risk derailing their entire season with a single injury to their starter. The difference between a capable backup and an inexperienced one can be the difference between a deep playoff run and an early exit. The 2024 NFL season will demonstrate this crucial factor more than ever.

Conclusion: Teams like the 49ers and Cowboys have significantly boosted their playoff chances by securing top-tier backup quarterbacks. Others need to take note: investing in a reliable backup isn't just a smart move; it's a necessity for any team with serious playoff ambitions. The 2024 NFL season will highlight the impact of these crucial second-string players. Who will rise to the occasion when called upon? Only time will tell.