Assessing The Backup QBs: Who Could Carry An NFL Team To The 2024 Playoffs?

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 13, 2025

4.8

Share

Assessing the Backup QBs: Who Could Carry an NFL Team to the 2024 Playoffs?

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One devastating injury to a star quarterback can unravel even the most meticulously crafted season. So, while fans focus on the starting quarterbacks vying for Super Bowl glory, the backup quarterbacks quietly hold the fate of many teams in their hands. But which of these understudies possess the talent and grit to not just fill in, but to lead their teams to the 2024 playoffs? Let's delve into the contenders.

The Top Tier: Proven Performers with Playoff Experience (or close)

Several backup quarterbacks have already shown flashes of brilliance, proving they can perform under pressure. This group represents the best chance for a team to maintain playoff contention in the event of a starting quarterback injury.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's remarkable late-season surge in 2022, culminating in a playoff run, cemented his place among the elite backup QBs. His performance speaks volumes about his ability to handle high-stakes situations. While his recovery from injury is crucial, if healthy, he’s the frontrunner in this category.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush stepped in admirably for Dak Prescott in 2021, showcasing his composure and game management skills. He’s not a flashy QB, but his reliability makes him a valuable asset for the Cowboys.

• Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew's experience as a starter gives him an edge. While his consistency might be questioned, his arm talent and improvisational skills could surprise many if thrust into a starting role.

The Second Tier: Potential Dark Horses with High Upside

This group possesses the potential to exceed expectations but lacks the same level of proven performance as the top tier. Their success hinges on their ability to adapt quickly to increased responsibility and withstand the pressure of leading an NFL team.

• Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): Though not yet a proven commodity, Grier has the physical tools and the experience to potentially surprise. His development will be a key storyline to watch in Dallas.

• Josh Dobbs (Cleveland Browns): Dobbs has bounced around the league, but his intelligence and athleticism make him a potentially intriguing backup option. His performance this season will be crucial for gauging his readiness to lead.

Factors Beyond Talent: Coaching and Team Dynamics

It's not just about the quarterback's individual skills. The success of a backup QB relies heavily on several other factors:

• Offensive Scheme: A simplified, run-heavy offense can mask a backup QB's weaknesses and leverage their strengths.
• Offensive Line Protection: A strong offensive line is crucial for any quarterback, but even more so for a backup who might lack experience.
• Strong Running Game: A robust ground game can take the pressure off the passing game, allowing the backup QB to manage the game effectively.
• Coaching Staff: A supportive and experienced coaching staff can provide the guidance and adjustments necessary for a backup QB to succeed.

Conclusion: Uncertainty Reigns Supreme

Predicting which backup QB will lead their team to the playoffs is inherently difficult. While some, like Brock Purdy, have demonstrated their capabilities, others remain unproven commodities. The 2023-2024 season will undoubtedly provide further insight into the depth and potential of these NFL understudies. The ultimate test, however, will be whether they can step up when called upon and lead their teams to unexpected playoff berths. Keep a close eye on these quarterbacks – they might just surprise you.