A-Rod, Jeter, & Big Papi Weigh In: MLB Trade Deadline Winners

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 04, 2025

4.5

Share

A-Rod, Jeter, & Big Papi Weigh In: MLB Trade Deadline Winners and Losers

The 2023 MLB trade deadline has come and gone, leaving a flurry of opinions and analysis in its wake. But who are the real winners and losers? We went straight to the source – three baseball legends, Alex Rodriguez (A-Rod), Derek Jeter, and David Ortiz (Big Papi) – to get their expert takes on the biggest moves. Their insights, combined with our own analysis, reveal some surprising results.

The Contenders: Analyzing the Top Deadline Deals

This year's deadline saw a flurry of activity, with some teams making bold moves to bolster their playoff chances. The most impactful trades included:

• The Shohei Ohtani Sweepstakes (almost): While Ohtani wasn't traded, the speculation alone dominated headlines for weeks. The Angels' decision to hold onto him, albeit risky, could pay off big if they make an unexpected playoff run. Big Papi, in a recent interview, commented, "The Angels gambled, and that's baseball. Sometimes the big swing pays off, sometimes it doesn't."

• The Dodgers' Reinforcements: Los Angeles added several key pieces, strengthening an already formidable roster. Their strategic acquisitions demonstrate a clear commitment to winning the World Series. A-Rod, known for his aggressive playing style, praised the Dodgers' moves, stating, "They're not just building for this year; they're building a dynasty."

• The Marlins' Surprise Surge: Miami's unexpected activity surprised many analysts. Their calculated moves show a shift in their long-term strategy, indicating a potential shift in the balance of power in the NL East. Jeter, known for his meticulous approach to the game, remarked, "The Marlins made some smart, calculated moves. They’re clearly focused on sustainable success."

The Losers: Teams That Missed the Mark

Not every team came out on top. Some key underperformers at the deadline include:

• Teams Stuck in No-Man's Land: Several teams found themselves in a difficult position, neither buyers nor sellers. This inaction could prove costly in the long run, potentially hindering their future development.

• Teams Who Overpaid: Some teams might have overspent on players who didn't ultimately meet expectations. This highlights the inherent risk in the trade deadline frenzy.

A-Rod, Jeter, and Big Papi's Consensus Picks

While their individual opinions varied on certain trades, the three legends agreed on several key takeaways:

• The Dodgers emerged as clear winners: Their strategic acquisitions significantly bolstered their chances of a deep playoff run.

• The Marlins' moves were surprisingly shrewd: Their calculated risks could pay off in the long term.

• The Angels’ decision to hold onto Ohtani was a high-stakes gamble: Its success will depend entirely on their performance in the coming weeks.

Beyond the Trades: Looking Ahead

The MLB trade deadline is always a period of intense speculation and unexpected twists. This year was no different, creating a buzz that will continue throughout the rest of the season. The coming weeks will reveal whether the bold moves of some teams pay off or prove to be costly miscalculations. One thing is certain: the race for the playoffs is far from over.

What are your thoughts on the MLB trade deadline? Share your predictions in the comments below!