2025 MLB Cy Young Contenders: Analyzing Paul Skenes' Odds Despite Early Season Struggles

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 12, 2025

4.8

Share

2025 MLB Cy Young Contenders: Can Paul Skenes Overcome Early Season Hurdles?

The 2024 MLB season is still unfolding, but baseball fans and analysts are already looking ahead to the 2025 Cy Young Award race. One name consistently mentioned amongst the early favorites is Pittsburgh Pirates pitching prodigy, Paul Skenes. However, a less-than-stellar start to his major league career has some questioning whether the hype surrounding the highly touted prospect can translate into real-world success and a legitimate shot at baseball's top pitching honor. This article analyzes Skenes' current performance, his potential, and his odds of winning the 2025 Cy Young Award.

Skenes' Promising Start, Then a Dip:

Skenes, the number one overall pick in the 2023 MLB Draft, arrived in Pittsburgh with immense expectations. His college career at LSU was nothing short of dominant, showcasing an electric fastball and a devastating slider. While he initially showed flashes of that dominance in his MLB debut, posting impressive strikeout numbers in his first few starts, a recent slump has raised concerns. Increased walks, higher ERA, and a noticeable dip in velocity have fueled the debate: is Skenes' early season struggle a temporary blip or a sign of things to come?

Analyzing the Challenges:

Several factors may contribute to Skenes' recent struggles. The adjustment to the major leagues is notoriously difficult for young pitchers. The increased competition, the constant scouting reports, and the pressure of performing at the highest level can all take a toll. Furthermore, minor mechanical adjustments or a simple case of fatigue could also be playing a role. Expert analysis points to the need for better command of his secondary pitches to complement his already impressive fastball.

• Increased Walk Rate: A significantly higher walk rate compared to his college days suggests a need for better command and control.
• Velocity Dip: A slight drop in fastball velocity might indicate fatigue or a need to refine his pitching mechanics.
• Adapting to MLB Hitters: Major league hitters are more patient and discerning, making it crucial for Skenes to develop more effective secondary pitches.

The Path to a 2025 Cy Young:

Despite his recent struggles, Skenes still possesses the raw talent to become a dominant force in the MLB. His electric fastball alone makes him a formidable opponent. However, his path to a 2025 Cy Young hinges on several key factors:

• Improved Command and Control: Developing better command of his pitches will be paramount to limiting walks and increasing his effectiveness.
• Refining Secondary Pitches: Developing a consistent breaking ball and changeup will be vital in keeping hitters off balance.
• Maintaining Physical Health: Avoiding injuries and maintaining peak physical condition are crucial for any starting pitcher aiming for Cy Young contention.
• Team Support: The Pirates' overall performance will also significantly impact Skenes' chances. A successful team generally leads to better individual statistics.

The Verdict: Still a Contender?

While Skenes' early-season struggles are undeniable, writing him off as a future Cy Young contender would be premature. His exceptional talent and potential remain undeniable. The coming months will be crucial in determining whether he can overcome these challenges and rediscover the dominance that made him a top draft pick. His ability to adapt, learn, and refine his skills will be the ultimate deciding factor in his 2025 Cy Young odds. It’s certainly a race worth watching!

What are your thoughts? Do you believe Paul Skenes can overcome his current struggles and become a Cy Young contender in 2025? Share your predictions in the comments below!