2025 MLB All-Star Projections: Full AL & NL Lineups & Controversies

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 17, 2025

4.7

Share

2025 MLB All-Star Projections: Full AL & NL Lineups & Controversies

Baseball fans, get ready! While the 2024 season is still in full swing, the baseball world is already buzzing with speculation about the 2025 MLB All-Star Game. This year promises a thrilling matchup, filled with both established superstars and exciting rising talent. But as always, predicting the All-Star lineups is a complex task, riddled with potential controversies and unexpected breakouts. Let's dive into our projections for the American League (AL) and National League (NL) lineups, and highlight some of the potential points of contention.

American League (AL) Projected Lineup:

The AL boasts a potent offensive lineup, making selecting just one team a significant challenge. Here's our projection, keeping in mind that injuries and unexpected performance changes can drastically alter the landscape:

• Catcher: Adley Rutschman (Orioles) - Rutschman's continued growth and defensive prowess make him a near-lock.
• First Base: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Blue Jays) - Despite some recent struggles, Vlad Jr.'s power and overall talent still place him among the elite.
• Second Base: Marcus Semien (Rangers) - A consistent performer, Semien’s bat and glove earn him a starting spot.
• Third Base: Rafael Devers (Red Sox) - Devers continues to be a cornerstone of the Red Sox, solidifying his place in the All-Star game.
• Shortstop: Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals) - The young star continues his ascent, potentially leading the AL in stolen bases.
• Left Field: Kyle Tucker (Astros) – A consistent hitter with significant power.
• Center Field: Julio Rodríguez (Mariners) - Rodríguez's speed and exciting play make him a fan favorite and a lock for the All-Star game.
• Right Field: Aaron Judge (Yankees) – Assuming health, Judge remains a force to be reckoned with.
• Designated Hitter: Shohei Ohtani (Angels) – The two-way superstar is a guaranteed selection.

Potential AL Controversies: The AL's biggest debate likely centers around the outfield spots. Players like Randy Arozarena (Rays) and Luis Robert Jr. (White Sox) will be pushing for starting roles, making the selection process incredibly competitive.

National League (NL) Projected Lineup:

The NL boasts a strong mix of young talent and veteran stars. Our projected lineup is:

• Catcher: Willson Contreras (St. Louis Cardinals) - Contreras's strong offensive output and leadership cement his place.
• First Base: Freddie Freeman (Dodgers) - A consistent performer and perennial All-Star, Freeman remains a cornerstone of the NL.
• Second Base: Luis Arraez (Marlins) - Arraez’s batting average prowess often makes him a standout candidate.
• Third Base: Nolan Arenado (Cardinals) - Arenado's defensive excellence and consistent hitting earn him a spot.
• Shortstop: Dansby Swanson (Cubs) - Swanson’s consistently excellent play earns him a starting role.
• Left Field: Mookie Betts (Dodgers) - Betts’ all-around skills are a must-have.
• Center Field: Michael Harris II (Braves) - Harris's impressive rookie season puts him in contention for a starting spot.
• Right Field: Juan Soto (Padres) – Soto’s plate discipline and hitting ability are unmatched.
• Pitcher: Spencer Strider (Braves) – A potential Cy Young candidate.

Potential NL Controversies: Competition for outfield spots is fierce in the NL, with players like Corbin Carroll (Diamondbacks) and Bryce Harper (Phillies), when healthy, posing significant challenges to the projected lineup. The debate around the best starting pitcher will also be a hot topic, with many talented arms vying for selection.

Conclusion:

Predicting the 2025 MLB All-Star Game rosters this early is always a speculative exercise. However, by considering current performance, projected growth, and potential injury factors, we can attempt to build a likely starting lineup for both the AL and the NL. The real excitement will come in watching the season unfold and seeing which players rise to the occasion to earn their spots in this prestigious event. Stay tuned for more updates as the season progresses! What are your predictions? Let us know in the comments below!