2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Ranking The Backup Quarterback Options

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 03, 2025

4.0

Share

2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Ranking the Backup Quarterback Options

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and even the most talented starting quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. For teams harboring playoff aspirations in 2024, the quality of their backup quarterback is paramount. A shaky understudy can derail even the most promising season. So, let's rank the backup quarterback situations of some key 2024 playoff contenders, analyzing their potential impact on their team's success.

Methodology: This ranking considers several factors, including the backup's experience, recent performance, familiarity with the offensive system, and overall talent. We're focusing on teams realistically expected to contend for a playoff spot.

Tier 1: The Secure Contenders

These teams boast backup quarterbacks who inspire confidence, minimizing the risk of significant drop-off should their starter go down.

• Kansas City Chiefs: While the specifics haven't been announced yet, the Chiefs consistently have a strong QB2, offering a solid contingency plan for Patrick Mahomes. Their scouting and development of young quarterbacks is a key factor here. Their history of success points to a strong backup, regardless of who it is.

• Buffalo Bills: The Bills are in a similar position to the Chiefs. They often have a high-quality QB2 ready to step in, although the specific name changes from year to year. Their dedication to maintaining depth at this crucial position suggests they'll continue this trend.

Tier 2: The Cautiously Optimistic

These teams have backups with potential, but perhaps lacking extensive starting experience or perfect fit within the offensive scheme.

• Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles' situation is interesting. While they might not have a star backup, their system is quarterback-friendly. Their backup’s ability to operate within the system effectively is crucial.

• Cincinnati Bengals: Similar to Philadelphia, Cincinnati’s success hinges on their system. Their backup’s familiarity with this system, rather than individual accolades, is the key metric.

Tier 3: The Question Marks

These teams' backup quarterback situations present more significant concerns. A starter injury could significantly impact their playoff chances.

• Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys' backup situation warrants close attention. Their success depends heavily on Dak Prescott’s health. A significant injury to Prescott would leave the Cowboys in a precarious position.

• San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers are perpetually in a state of quarterback flux, making their backup situation a significant wildcard. Their success is heavily reliant on their starting quarterback remaining healthy.

Factors to Consider Beyond the Roster:

• Offensive Line: A strong offensive line can mitigate the weaknesses of a less experienced backup quarterback.
• Coaching Staff: A capable coaching staff can adapt the game plan to suit the strengths of the backup quarterback.
• Team Depth: Beyond the quarterback position, a team's overall depth at other positions influences its resilience to injuries.

Conclusion:

The NFL is a game of inches, and sometimes, those inches are defined by the quality of the backup quarterback. While predicting the future is impossible, analyzing the current situations provides valuable insight into the potential vulnerabilities of 2024's playoff contenders. The teams in Tier 1 have a clear advantage, but even they aren't immune to unforeseen circumstances. The teams in Tier 3, however, face a steeper climb to the playoffs should their starters get injured. Stay tuned for further developments as the 2024 season approaches!

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on these rankings? Share your predictions for the 2024 NFL season in the comments below!