2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Ranking Backup Quarterback Potential

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 20, 2025

4.7

Share

2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Ranking Backup Quarterback Potential

The NFL playoffs are a brutal crucible, where even the slightest injury can derail a Super Bowl dream. While every team strives for a dominant starting quarterback, the quality of the backup often goes unnoticed until it's desperately needed. This year, the strength (or weakness) of a team's second-string QB might be the unexpected factor determining playoff success. Let's dive into a ranking of the 2024 playoff contenders based on their backup quarterback potential.

Tier 1: The Secure Backups

These teams boast backups capable of stepping in and maintaining a high level of play, minimizing the disruption caused by a starter's injury.

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While Chad Henne's retirement leaves a void, the Chiefs consistently prioritize strong quarterback depth. Their backup, whoever it may be, will likely be a seasoned veteran with a proven track record, ensuring continuity within the offense. This makes them a top contender, regardless of who ultimately fills the role.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles’ quarterback room is a testament to shrewd roster management. Their backup possesses the experience and talent to effectively run the offense, should Jalen Hurts face any setbacks. Their depth at the position provides a significant competitive edge.

Tier 2: The Promising Understudies

These teams have promising backups, but there's a slightly higher degree of uncertainty regarding their performance under pressure.

3. Buffalo Bills: The Bills have historically shown a commitment to developing strong backup quarterbacks. While their current backup might not have the same level of experience as those in Tier 1, their potential for growth and familiarity with the system could prove crucial.

4. Cincinnati Bengals: Similar to Buffalo, Cincinnati's focus on quarterback development bodes well for their backup's potential. However, consistent performance at the highest level remains to be seen.

Tier 3: The Question Marks

These teams' backup quarterback situations present significant risk. A starter's injury could dramatically alter their playoff chances.

5. Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys' backup situation is a cause for concern. While they've had some success with journeyman quarterbacks in the past, the lack of a proven, reliable option behind Dak Prescott represents a considerable vulnerability.

6. San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' situation is unique. While they possess talented quarterbacks, injuries have plagued the position in recent years. The consistency and readiness of their backup remain a question mark heading into the season.

Factors Beyond the Player: Coaching and System

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success isn't solely reliant on individual talent. The coaching staff's ability to adapt the offensive scheme and the team's overall resilience play significant roles. A well-coached team can often mitigate the impact of an injured starter better than a team with internal strife. This factor significantly influences how teams in each tier perform when facing adversity.

Conclusion: Depth Chart Dynamics

The quality of a team's backup quarterback is a frequently overlooked aspect of NFL success. While starting quarterback performance is paramount, the reliability of the second-stringer can be the difference between a deep playoff run and an early exit. As the 2024 season unfolds, keeping an eye on backup quarterback play will be just as important as monitoring the starting quarterbacks. Teams with strong backup quarterbacks undoubtedly have a significant competitive advantage in the race for the Super Bowl. Who will rise to the occasion when called upon? Only time will tell.