2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Evaluating The Backup Quarterback Options

David

3 min read

Post on May 20, 2025

4.3

Share

2024 NFL Playoff Contenders: Evaluating the Backup Quarterback Options

The NFL playoffs are a brutal crucible. One injury, one unexpected slump from a starting quarterback, and a team's Super Bowl hopes can vanish faster than a Hail Mary. This year, more than ever, the quality of backup quarterbacks is a critical factor in determining which teams will truly contend for a championship. While star power grabs headlines, the depth at the quarterback position could be the unsung hero (or villain) of the 2024 season.

This article dives deep into several playoff contenders, analyzing their backup quarterback situations and determining how much confidence each team should have in their second-string signal-callers. We'll explore experience, potential, and the overall impact these players could have on their team's success.

AFC Contenders: Backup QB Analysis

Kansas City Chiefs: The Chiefs, perennial contenders, boast a reliable backup in Blaine Gabbert. His experience and familiarity with Andy Reid's offensive system offer a degree of comfort. However, a significant drop-off in talent is expected if Patrick Mahomes is sidelined. The Chiefs' offensive firepower might compensate, but relying heavily on their defense and running game would be a risk.

Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's health is paramount for Buffalo. Their backup situation, however, presents a considerable concern. While the team has options, none offer the same level of competence as Allen. This lack of a reliable backup significantly impacts their playoff ceiling. A serious Allen injury could easily derail their season.

Cincinnati Bengals: The Bengals have shown faith in Brandon Allen, but his performance has been inconsistent. The team's success hinges on Joe Burrow's health, highlighting a critical vulnerability should he suffer an injury. Upgrading this position should be a priority for the Bengals’ front office.

NFC Contenders: Backup QB Scrutiny

Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles' situation is comparatively stronger than many contenders. Jalen Hurts' durability is a concern, but Gardner Minshew offers a capable and experienced alternative. He’s proven capable of stepping in and managing games, providing the Eagles with a much-needed insurance policy.

San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' quarterback room is a fascinating case study. Trey Lance, Brock Purdy, and Sam Darnold all bring different levels of experience and potential. The question is less about competency and more about consistency. The team's overall depth at the position, however, provides a clear advantage in terms of handling unexpected situations. This is arguably the best backup situation amongst all contenders.

Dallas Cowboys: Cooper Rush has proven to be a reliable game manager, providing a solid safety net for Dak Prescott. While he may not possess the same high-ceiling talent as Prescott, he offers experience and the ability to keep the Cowboys competitive should the need arise. The Cowboys have a solid, if unspectacular, backup plan.

The Importance of Backup QBs in Playoff Contentions

The impact of a quality backup quarterback cannot be overstated. The 2024 NFL season will likely be determined, in part, by the performance of these often-overlooked players. Teams investing in a reliable backup are actively mitigating risk and significantly increasing their chances of postseason success.

This season, the gap between starting and backup quarterbacks could prove to be the difference between a Super Bowl appearance and an early exit. Teams should assess their backup quarterback situation carefully, as the quality of the second-stringer may well decide the fate of their playoff aspirations.

Want to stay updated on the latest NFL news and analysis? Follow us on [Social Media Link]!