2019 NFL Draft's Top 10: A Retrospective Analysis Of Success And Failure

David

4 min read

Post on Jun 13, 2025

4.0

Share

2019 NFL Draft's Top 10: A Retrospective Analysis of Success and Failure

The 2019 NFL Draft is now firmly in the rearview mirror, offering a prime opportunity for a retrospective analysis of its top ten picks. Did these highly touted prospects live up to the hype? Did teams make shrewd selections or costly mistakes? Let's delve into the successes and failures of this draft class, examining the careers of these players and the impact they've had on their respective franchises.

Kyler Murray (No. 1 Overall, Arizona Cardinals): A Mixed Bag

The Arizona Cardinals' decision to select Kyler Murray first overall was met with mixed reactions. While his electrifying playmaking ability is undeniable, injuries and inconsistency have hampered his career. Murray possesses exceptional talent, but questions remain about his long-term durability and ability to consistently elevate the Cardinals to championship contention. His future in Arizona, following a recent trade request, remains uncertain. [Link to article about Murray's trade request]

Nick Bosa (No. 2 Overall, San Francisco 49ers): A Defensive Juggernaut

The San Francisco 49ers made a savvy pick with Nick Bosa. He quickly established himself as one of the league's premier pass rushers, consistently disrupting opposing offenses. Bosa's impact on the 49ers' defense has been significant, earning him numerous accolades and solidifying his position as a cornerstone of their franchise. [Link to Bosa's NFL.com player profile]

Quinnen Williams (No. 3 Overall, New York Jets): Flashes of Brilliance, Room for Growth

The New York Jets selected Quinnen Williams hoping for an immediate impact. While he's shown flashes of brilliance, consistency has been an issue. His potential is undeniable, but injuries and a sometimes inconsistent performance have prevented him from reaching the elite level many predicted.

Josh Allen (No. 4 Overall, Jacksonville Jaguars): A Disappointment?

Many analysts questioned the Jacksonville Jaguars' decision to draft Josh Allen at this high pick, and unfortunately, those doubts have largely been validated. Allen has failed to live up to expectations as a consistent force on the defensive line. This selection highlights the inherent risks involved in the NFL Draft.

Jonah Williams (No. 11 Overall, Cincinnati Bengals - traded up): A Solid but Unremarkable Career

Originally selected by the Bengals, Jonah Williams has established himself as a reliable offensive lineman. However, he hasn't quite reached the superstar status predicted for a top-ten pick. His career has been hampered by injuries, preventing him from consistently showcasing his full potential.

T.J. Hockenson (No. 8 Overall, Detroit Lions): A Reliable Tight End

The Detroit Lions’ selection of T.J. Hockenson has proven to be a successful one. Hockenson has become a dependable target, showcasing his strong hands and ability to make tough catches. While he hasn't quite reached elite status, he's consistently performed well.

Brian Burns (No. 16 Overall, Carolina Panthers - traded up): A Consistent Performer

Though not strictly a top 10 pick, Burns deserves mention here given his trade up and subsequent impact. He's consistently performed well for the Panthers, exhibiting great speed and pass-rushing skills, showing that trading up can sometimes be a successful strategy.

Montez Sweat (No. 26 Overall, Washington Redskins - traded up): A Solid Pass Rusher

Similar to Burns, Sweat's performance is notable despite a slightly lower draft position and trade up. He's become a reliable pass rusher for his team, highlighting the value of athleticism in the NFL.

Rashan Gary (No. 12 Overall, Green Bay Packers): Steady Improvement

Rashan Gary, selected by the Green Bay Packers, has shown steady improvement throughout his career. While he didn’t immediately become a superstar, his consistent development and contributions to the Packers' defense mark him as a solid selection.

Devin White (No. 5 Overall, Tampa Bay Buccaneers): A Defensive Leader

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ choice of Devin White has been a largely successful one. White has evolved into a key part of their defense, displaying leadership and making significant contributions. His impact transcends mere statistics; he's a crucial player for the Buccaneers.

Conclusion: Lessons Learned from the 2019 NFL Draft

The 2019 NFL Draft serves as a stark reminder of the inherent unpredictability of the NFL. While some selections, like Nick Bosa, have been resounding successes, others have fallen short of expectations. This retrospective highlights the importance of evaluating not only talent but also character, injury history, and fit within a team's scheme. The NFL Draft is a complex process, and the 2019 class provides valuable insights for future scouting and player development.

What are your thoughts on the 2019 NFL Draft's top ten picks? Share your opinions in the comments below!