2019 NFL Draft's Top 10: A Retrospective Analysis Of Success

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 13, 2025

4.0

Share

2019 NFL Draft's Top 10: A Retrospective Analysis of Success and Failure

The 2019 NFL Draft boasted a star-studded class, with several quarterbacks and elite defensive players projected to become franchise cornerstones. Three years later, how have those top ten picks fared? This retrospective analysis dives deep into the successes and disappointments, examining the careers of these highly touted prospects and assessing their overall impact on their respective teams.

The Kyler Murray Gamble and Beyond:

The Arizona Cardinals’ selection of Kyler Murray first overall was a bold move, and one that has yielded mixed results. While undeniably talented, showcasing impressive rushing ability and a strong arm, Murray's injury history and consistency issues have hampered his development. His career trajectory highlights the inherent risk in selecting quarterbacks so high, even with their undeniable potential. [Link to article analyzing Kyler Murray's career]. This selection, however, did set the tone for a draft heavily focused on immediate impact players.

Defensive Dominance and Disappointment:

The 2019 draft was rich with defensive talent. Nick Bosa (San Francisco 49ers, #2 overall), arguably the safest pick in the draft, has lived up to the hype, quickly establishing himself as one of the league's premier pass rushers. His consistent performance underscores the value of selecting elite defensive talent early. Conversely, the performance of some other defensive picks has been less predictable. Quinnen Williams (New York Jets, #3 overall) has shown flashes of brilliance but hasn't consistently dominated as expected. This highlights the complexities of projecting defensive success in the NFL, where scheme fit and supporting cast play crucial roles.

Offensive Line Struggles and Surprising Successes:

The offensive line was another focal point in the 2019 draft. Jonah Williams (Cincinnati Bengals, #11 overall) battled injuries early, hindering his progression. However, other offensive linemen drafted later in the first round proved to be more impactful. This underscores that finding value later in the first round or even in later rounds can often be just as beneficial.

Analyzing the Top 10:

Here’s a breakdown of the top 10 picks from the 2019 NFL Draft and a retrospective analysis of their careers:

• 1. Kyler Murray (QB, Arizona Cardinals): Showed flashes of brilliance but plagued by injuries and inconsistency.
• 2. Nick Bosa (DE, San Francisco 49ers): A resounding success, established himself as an elite pass rusher.
• 3. Quinnen Williams (DT, New York Jets): Potential unrealized, inconsistent performance.
• 4. Josh Allen (LB, Jacksonville Jaguars): Solid contributor but hasn't reached elite status.
• 5. Devin White (LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers): A key part of a Super Bowl winning team, showcasing impressive athleticism and playmaking ability.
• 6. T.J. Hockenson (TE, Detroit Lions): A productive tight end, though his team's struggles have limited his overall impact.
• 7. Montez Sweat (DE, Washington Redskins): A solid pass rusher, consistently contributing to the defense.
• 8. Ed Oliver (DT, Buffalo Bills): Showed promise but hasn't quite lived up to expectations.
• 9. Jawaan Taylor (OT, Jacksonville Jaguars): A reliable offensive tackle, contributing to the team’s run game.
• 10. Daniel Jones (QB, New York Giants): Inconsistent performance, raising questions about his long-term viability as a franchise quarterback.

Lessons Learned:

The 2019 NFL Draft serves as a reminder that even the highest draft picks are not guaranteed successes. The interplay of talent, coaching, scheme fit, and injury significantly impacts a player's development. Teams must carefully assess these factors when making high-stakes draft decisions. While some players like Nick Bosa have exceeded expectations, others, like Kyler Murray and Quinnen Williams, represent the inherent risk in the NFL draft process. The journey for these top-ten picks underscores the ever-evolving nature of evaluating talent in the NFL.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on the 2019 draft class? Share your opinions in the comments below!